The Project File Details
This work evaluates the economic viability of using mini Gas-to-liquid technology for the monetization of associated stranded flared gas at Izombe location, in the Niger Delta, Nigeria. The Izombe field has been noted as the area of large production of associated gas. This gas has been stranded and thus flared because of lack of proximity to market. The average 40mmscfd of Izombe flared gas is to be put to monetization. The volume available for monetization after preliminary treatment and NGL recover corresponds to 32.07mmscfd. This volume yields a GTL product of 3207b/d of diesel. The Fisher Tropsch synthesis reaction method was used for the conversion of the synthesis gas to diesel using iron catalysts. The economic analysis identified several economic factors that characterizes the economic profitability of the project. An economic model was developed which was simulated in MATLAB script known as GTL.m for the simulation of results. The results of the sensitivity analyses show that the CAPEX has significant impact on the overall profitability of the project. The results also reveal that the OPEX has negligible effect on the NPV of the project. Economic factors such as diesel price, natural gas price and discount rates all have serious impact on the profitability of the project. From the results it is seen that the project will always yield positive NPV as long as the natural gas price is below $1.5/Mscf for all discount rates. And for a discount rate of 29.3% the project yields positive NPV for diesel price of $67/bbl and above.
A good percentage of natural gas reserve is stranded in deep offshore locations, in difficult and remote areas or produced as associated gas. Bringing these stranded gases to the market is usually challenging especially when distance makes pipelining economically prohibitive.
The availability of the resources for the end users is therefore hampered by production and transportation costs which can exceed the price at which the gas can be sold. In such situations, innovative technical means are needed for reducing the costs and providing new outlets for natural gas.
When lack of facilities for transmission and distribution is available, there is only a limited number of outlets for the associated gas. This includes a re-injection (for pressure maintenance or for future recovery) and gas flaring. Gas flaring is the controlled burning of the associated gas in the atmosphere and it is a global environmental issue.
In order to address the issues of gas flaring, it is important to understand the reasons why natural gas is being flared. Since oil and natural gas are mixed in every oil deposit, natural gas called “associated gas” must be removed from oil before refining (Ashton et al, 1999). Gas flaring is simply the burning of this associated gas. Issues of gas flaring is currently illegal in most countries of the world, and may occur in certain circumstances such as emergency shutdowns, non-planned maintenance, or disruption to the processing system (Hyne, 1991). Recently, 56.6 million m3 of associated gas is flared every day in Nigeria (Gerth and Labaton, 2004). In 2002, Nigeria has the world’s highest level of gas flaring, and it flares 16 percent of the world’s total associated gas (GGFR 2002). Due to lack of infrastructure, approximately 76 percent of associated gas is flared in Nigeria, compared to 8 percent in Alberta, Canada (Africa News Service 2003, Watts 2001).
Nigeria had regulations on the books banning gas flaring for more than a quarter of a century, however they are yet to effectively implement their policies. In 1969, the Nigerian government legislated a requirement that charged oil companies to set up infrastructures to utilize the associated gas within five years of commencement of oil production (Manby, 1999). The government also enacted the Associated Gas Reinjection Act in 1979, which charged oil companies to stop gas flaring within five years (Manby 1999). However, the companies preferred to pay the fine imposed by the government as a penalty for gas flaring rather than stopping the flaring. Although the fine for gas flaring has skyrocketed from Naira 0, 5 to Naira 10 (U.S. 11 ¢) for every 1,000 ft3 of gas in 1998 (Manby 1999, Project Underground 2003), but this fine is still very low to have an impact on these companies’ policy toward gas flaring. Moreover, approximately $3 million per month of fines that the government receives is just a fraction of what it could impose.
The reason for high rate of gas flaring in Nigeria is primarily due to;
The attendant impact of gas flaring in Nigeria cannot be over-estimated. Aside the billions of dollars lost annually to gas flaring when quantified financially, a lot of other impacts of gas flaring is noticeable in Nigeria. The severe environmental degradation of the ecosystem resulting to loss of ecological lives, emergence of sicknesses, air, water and land pollutions, release of poisonous gases that hampers human habitation, release of greenhouse gases resulting to global warming to mention but a few. With all these, the Niger Delta region of Nigeria can be said to be the area most impacted by oil activities in the world.
In most favourable situations, where a transport network and market are available, the gas is processed and heavy fractions are extracted as Natural Gas Liquids (NGLs). When the injection does not enhance oil recovery, its cost is not compensated by a specific benefit. Therefore, new capital intensive projects are now more and more considered as LNG production and GTL schemes. It can be considered that about 30% of the associated gas reserves are stranded.
Gas to liquids technology is the chemical conversion of the natural gas into liquid fuels by use of many available technologies. The method provides premium liquid fuels that burns cleaner and sells higher than the conventional crude oil fractions.
The choice of GTL is this study because LNG has been existing and is capital intensive. The use of mini-GTL technologies to capture and process stranded gases that otherwise were candidate for flaring forms the basis of this research work.
There is vast volume of stranded natural gas in the Niger Delta. These gases have been flared by operating companies because of their inability to harness the gas to useful means. As a result, Russia and Nigeria is topping the nations in annual gas flared. The recent laws on greenhouse gas reduction have forced many countries to find measures to curtail its gas flaring activities. For this to be achieved gas projects must be developed. This is aimed at capturing and monetizing the gas for use by consumers. This problem is what monetization alternative quest for. Although many monetization options exist for the flared natural gas. These options must address the market demand and supply and the availability and locations of the gas must also be considered in the analyses. Gas-to-liquids technology is the conversion of the natural gas into premium liquid fuels which can be used in the liquid forms. By these the gases can be harnessed and monetized.
The use of mini GTL plants solves the problem of commercial volume. Mini portable GTL plants can be utilized and carried from one field location to the other or can be located to capture the gas other than having to lay pipelines to the central facility.
The objectives of this research work are
The methodology shall comprise these parts;
The processing part talks about the treatment and recovery of the methane gas which shall serve as the feed stream gas to be fed into GTL plant.
The conversion of the gas to liquids employs many technologies of which the Fischer Tropsch method is the most popular and the one used in this work. There are basically three steps or processes in a typical Fischer Tropsch approach for GTL conversion. They are
This is also called reforming. There are three processes to converts natural gas into synthesis gas:
a). Steam Reforming:
The reaction is as follows
CH4 + H2O ↔ CO + 3H2 ΔH 25oC = +49.3Kcal/mol
High temperature (730 – 900oC) and it is an endothermic reaction.
Water gas shift formation as side reaction
CO + H2 ↔CO2 +H2 ΔH = -9.7Kcal/mol
This reaction is commercially applied in ammonia plants, fertilizer and methanol.
b). Partial oxidation
Reaction is as follows
CH4 + 1/2 O2 → CO + 2H2 ΔH 25oC = -8.5Kcal/mol
Catalysts: transition metal (Al)
Synthesis gas ratio: H2/CO = 2
c). CO2 Reforming
Reaction is as follows
CH4 + CO2 → 2CO + 2H2 ΔH = +59Kcal/mol
More endothermic than steam reforming
The next step in converting the syngas into a mixture of liquid and wax in a reaction using FT reaction as follows
nCO + 2nH2 → (CH2)n + nH2O ΔH 25oC = -40Kczl/mol.
The reaction takes place at 200 – 500oC and 148 atm, the products may vary as olefins, paraffins, or alcohol depends on catalysts.
This is also called product work-up and it is the last step in the gas to liquid conversion through the FT process. This is where the wax produced is converted into room temperature liquids that can travel in an oil pipeline or oil tanker.
Figure 1: FT GTL process flow diagram, showing the three main stages
The next aspect in the methodology is the evaluation of the technical and economic considerations of the GTL technology. In this the cost and revenue basis of the work is considered.
Overall consideration areas in the work include:
This work shall revolve around the conversion of the flared natural gas in the Niger delta to liquids using the Fischer Tropsch synthesis method. The gas here is strictly associated gas from oil wells that would have been candidate for flaring but harnessed and monetized. The work shall take a case of Izombe in Oguta. The case study is to evaluate the possibility of achieving zero flaring in Izombe by the use of mini GTL facilities located at the field locations to target the associated gas in that location. Since the problem of volume of gas to be harness is one crucial problem in GTL operations, the use of mini and portable GTL facility solve that problem.
It is to be noted that the work is not a complete feasibility study of GTL operations but a monetization alternative that would encourage investors to participate by highlighting the possibility and relative extent of revenue generation when venturing into gas monetization using GTL technologies in the Niger Delta.
This research work shall be a major contribution to knowledge in the area of flared gas monetization. It will reveal the cost of initiating gas to liquid project in the Niger Delta and the profitability and economic viability of venturing into mini GTL project in Nigeria. It will encourage investor’s participation in the area of flared gas monetization. The use of mini GTL shall be a new innovative means of monetizing stranded flared gases in areas that are not closer to the existing gas gathering stations.